Wicked Aloe Vera vs Simply Natural Lube: Sensitive Skin Pick
By CheapLubes.com | Published: 2026-11-05
Category: Comparisons
Both Wicked lubes are water-based and gentle, but they cushion differently. Compare Aloe Vera and Simply Natural on ingredients, slip, and sensitive-skin fit.
Quick answer
Choose Wicked Aloe Vera Based Lubricant if you want a thicker, plush gel with extra cushion for prolonged play. Choose Wicked Simply Natural if you want a lighter, fragrance-free water-based lube for everyday hydration and sensitive skin.
What actually differs between these two Wicked lubes
Both are water-based, both are made with aloe and olive leaf extract, and both are designed to be kind to sensitive skin. The difference is texture and intent. Wicked Aloe Vera is described as a thick-yet-slick gel that provides extra cushion, while Wicked Simply Natural is described as a gentle, fragrance-free formula that offers deeper hydration. That means Aloe Vera leans toward longer sessions where you want a physical buffer, and Simply Natural leans toward daily comfort and a lighter feel.
Neither product is marketed as a numbing or desensitizing lube, and neither catalog entry lists a pH value or a specific osmolality figure. If your sensitivity is tied to a diagnosed condition, those missing specs matter more than texture, so check with a clinician before relying on either.
The trade-off: cushion versus lightness
A thicker gel like Wicked Aloe Vera can reduce friction during extended play, but it may feel heavier or leave more residue than a lighter formula. Wicked Simply Natural's lighter water-based texture is easier to reapply and less noticeable, but it may not provide the same physical buffer for long sessions. There is no free option that gives maximum cushion and maximum lightness at once; pick based on how long you typically play and how much texture you want to feel.
Ingredient notes that matter for irritation-prone skin
Wicked Aloe Vera is explicitly glycerin- and propylene glycol-free, which is a meaningful detail if you have reacted to either ingredient before. Wicked Simply Natural is fragrance-free, which is a meaningful detail if added scent is your trigger. The catalogs do not state that Simply Natural is glycerin-free, so do not assume it is. If you are avoiding glycerin specifically, Aloe Vera is the safer documented choice between the two.
How to choose between them
- If you want extra cushion for longer sessions: Pick Wicked Aloe Vera Based Lubricant. Its thick-yet-slick gel is designed to provide extra cushion for prolonged play. Reapply water-based lube as it dries rather than adding more than you need at once.
- If you want a lighter everyday lube: Pick Wicked Simply Natural. Its gentle, fragrance-free water-based formula is built for lasting hydration and comfort.
- If you are avoiding glycerin or propylene glycol: Choose Wicked Aloe Vera, which is documented as glycerin- and propylene glycol-free. Simply Natural's catalog entry does not make that claim. Check the full ingredient list on the bottle before first use if you have known sensitivities.
- If you are avoiding fragrance: Choose Wicked Simply Natural, which is explicitly fragrance-free. Aloe Vera's catalog entry does not state fragrance status.
Product facts at a glance
- Wicked Aloe Vera Based Lubricant 4 oz: Glycerin- and propylene glycol-free, latex friendly, and safe with all toys. If you have reacted to glycerin or propylene glycol before, this is the documented choice between the two.
Wicked Aloe Vera Based Lubricant 4 oz - Wicked Simply Natural Water-Based Lubricant 4oz (120mL): Fragrance-free water-based formula with aloe, olive leaf extract, vitamin E, carrageenan, and sodium hyaluronate. A lighter, scent-free option for everyday use when added fragrance is your main irritation trigger.
Wicked Simply Natural Water-Based Lubricant 4oz (120mL)
Who each lube fits
Best for
- People who want a thicker, plush gel with extra cushion for prolonged play
- Sensitive-skin users who specifically avoid glycerin and propylene glycol
- Latex condom and toy users who need a water-based formula
Not for
- People who prefer a barely-there, lightweight lube texture
- Users who need a documented fragrance-free formula and cannot confirm Aloe Vera's scent status
- Anyone with a diagnosed sensitivity who needs pH or osmolality data before choosing
